Review of work

The table for review of work can be downloaded here >>>.

 

TITLE OF THE PUBLICATION:
MATERIAL PROTECTION

 

 COMMENTS AND RECOMMENDATIONS OF REVIEWERS

Manuscript ID:
xxxxxxxxx/15

 

NAME OF MANUSCRIPT:

Reviewers:

Name:

 

 

Dear Sir,

 

please complete the questionnaire. Also, certain suggestions and comments can mark directly on the manuscript, which is attached.

 

1. Thematic concept journal

___ The manuscript is in accordance with the scope of the journal

___ The manuscript is not in accordance with the scope of the journal

 

2. Title of manuscript

___ The title is appropriate

___ The title is not appropriate

 

3. Abstract

___ Abstract is appropriate to the theme of the manuscript

___ Abstract is not appropriate to the theme of the manuscript

 

4. Originality and significance

___ Similar manuscripts have been published by authors

___ Similar manuscripts have been published by other authors

___ There are high elements of originality

 

5. The scientific contribution of the manuscript

___ excellent
___ Good
___ Marginal
___ Low

___ The manuscript has certain omissions and errors in the scientific sense

 

6. Figures and tables

___ excellent

___ Good
___ Satisfactory
___ Impoverished

 

7.  Conclusions

___ Conclusions are Based on the present data and facts

___ Conclusions are not Based on the present data and facts

 

8. References

___ The allegations are properly quoted

___ The allegations are not properly quoted

 

9. Language

___ The manuscript is grammatically correct

___ It takes a certain revision proofreaders

 

10. Recommendation

___ The manuscript is acceptable in current form

___ The manuscript is acceptable with minor corrections

___ The manuscript requires more corrections and additional review

___ The manuscript is not acceptable in any circumstances

 

 

Comments reviewer author:

 

 

 

 

 

 

Comments reviewer Editorial Board:

 
 

 

 

 

Date:                                                                                                   Signature

 

 

 

The table for review of work can be downloaded here >>>.